York, Maine is more than just a picturesque coastal town—it’s a hub for some of the freshest, most authentic seafood experiences in New England. Nestled between rocky cliffs and the Atlantic Ocean, York’s seafood scene is directly tied to the town’s rich fishing history, ensuring that diners can enjoy the day’s catch straight from the local waters. Whether you’re indulging in a lobster roll with a view of Nubble Lighthouse or savoring fresh oysters by the beach, seafood in York is as much about the experience as it is the food.
For visitors staying at York Cabin, this culinary journey is just steps away, allowing you to blend fine dining with the natural beauty that defines this coastal retreat. In this guide, we uncover the best seafood spots in York, offering both upscale and casual options to suit every traveler’s taste.
The Coastal Flavors That Define York’s Seafood Scene
York, Maine’s seafood scene is a reflection of its unique geographic location—where the cold waters of the Atlantic meet the rugged coastline, providing some of the freshest seafood in the region. The town’s fishing heritage is central to its identity, and the proximity to local fisheries allows restaurants to offer dishes that highlight the flavors of the ocean in their purest form. What truly defines York’s seafood scene is its emphasis on sustainability and local sourcing, ensuring that the seafood you enjoy is often caught the very same day.
While many coastal towns serve lobster rolls and clam chowder, York elevates these dishes through the use of local ingredients and traditional preparation methods passed down over generations. Many of York’s seafood establishments embrace a “dock-to-table” philosophy, where the seafood travels directly from the boat to your plate. It’s not uncommon to enjoy oysters or mussels harvested just a few miles away from where you’re dining.
The charm of York’s seafood offerings lies not only in their freshness but in the dining experiences they create. Whether it’s an oceanfront meal at sunset or a casual lunch overlooking the harbor, the culinary scene here allows visitors to fully savor the flavors that make coastal Maine a seafood lover’s paradise.
Top 7 Seafood Restaurants in York, Maine
York, Maine’s seafood scene offers an extraordinary mix of flavors, settings, and local traditions. From casual beachfront shacks to upscale oceanfront dining, each restaurant brings its own take on fresh Maine seafood. Whether you’re craving a classic lobster roll or something more refined, York’s top spots have you covered. Now, let’s dive into the seven best seafood places this coastal town has to offer.
1. Fox’s Lobster House: Iconic Lobster Rolls with Lighthouse Views
Perched near the iconic Nubble Lighthouse, Fox’s Lobster House offers one of the most scenic seafood experiences in York, Maine. Established in 1966, this family-run restaurant has perfected the art of the lobster roll. Their lobster is caught fresh, boiled daily on-site, and served in a classic New England style—tender chunks of lobster, lightly dressed with butter or mayo, nestled in a toasted roll.
What sets Fox’s apart isn’t just the quality of the seafood, but the unparalleled views. Diners can enjoy their meals while overlooking the Atlantic, with Nubble Lighthouse serving as the perfect backdrop. Whether seated inside the cozy dining room or outside on the terrace, the combination of fresh lobster and panoramic ocean views makes Fox’s an unforgettable destination.
Beyond the lobster rolls, Fox’s offers a wide range of seafood, including fried clams, chowders, and the crowd-pleasing twin lobster special. It’s a must-visit for anyone looking to experience quintessential Maine dining with a view.
2. Lobster Cove: Oceanfront Dining with Local Charm
Lobster Cove is a gem in York, offering a perfect combination of local charm and breathtaking oceanfront views. Situated right on York Beach, this casual yet inviting seafood spot allows guests to enjoy their meals with the sound of crashing waves in the background. Whether you choose to dine on the outdoor patio in the summer or cozy up indoors by the fireplace in the winter, the atmosphere at Lobster Cove is both relaxing and quintessentially coastal.
The menu at Lobster Cove celebrates local seafood, with their lobster dishes being the highlight. The lobster stew and baked stuffed lobster are particularly popular, each bursting with fresh flavors and showcasing Maine’s best catch. Their clam chowder, with its rich, creamy texture, is another must-try, especially for those seeking a true taste of New England.
Lobster Cove is the perfect spot for visitors seeking a laid-back seafood experience without sacrificing quality. The combination of fresh, local seafood and stunning views makes it a top destination for both locals and travelers looking to immerse themselves in York’s coastal charm.
3. York River Landing: Craft Beer and Seafood by the River
York River Landing offers a unique blend of fresh seafood and a robust craft beer selection, all while providing scenic views of the York River. This trendy yet laid-back restaurant is a hit for those who want to enjoy Maine’s finest seafood in a casual, welcoming setting. Located along Route 1, York River Landing combines locally sourced seafood with an upscale pub-style menu, making it a favorite among both locals and visitors.
Signature dishes like their raw bar offerings, including fresh oysters and littleneck clams, bring the taste of the coast to your table. For those looking for something heartier, the seafood pasta or lobster mac and cheese are excellent choices, each packed with fresh flavors and perfectly cooked seafood. What sets York River Landing apart is the way they pair these dishes with their extensive craft beer selection, making it an ideal spot for seafood lovers and craft beer enthusiasts alike.
With its comfortable riverside setting and diverse menu, York River Landing is perfect for a relaxed meal where guests can savor both Maine’s seafood bounty and its growing craft beer culture.
4. Shearwater at Stage Neck Inn: Upscale Dining with Fresh Maine Lobster
For those seeking an upscale dining experience that highlights the best of Maine’s seafood, Shearwater at Stage Neck Inn delivers on all fronts. Located in the picturesque Stage Neck Inn, this restaurant offers diners panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean while they enjoy some of the freshest seafood in York. The setting is luxurious yet relaxed, perfect for those looking to elevate their dining experience with both ambiance and exquisite cuisine.
The star of the menu is, unsurprisingly, the fresh Maine lobster. Whether you opt for a classic steamed lobster or a more refined lobster bisque, Shearwater’s culinary team ensures that every dish is impeccably prepared. In addition to lobster, the menu features a variety of seasonal seafood dishes such as seared scallops and fresh oysters, making the most of the region’s daily catch.
What truly sets Shearwater apart is the attention to detail, both in service and presentation. Guests can enjoy their meal while soaking in the coastal beauty that surrounds them, making Shearwater an ideal choice for a special occasion or a memorable night out. It’s a quintessential Maine seafood experience, wrapped in elegance and sophistication.
5. 1637 Restaurant at York Harbor Inn: Coastal Elegance and Seafood Classics
Nestled within the historic York Harbor Inn, 1637 Restaurant offers a dining experience that combines coastal elegance with traditional New England seafood classics. The restaurant’s ambiance reflects the inn’s maritime charm, with its cozy, nautical-inspired interiors and stunning views of York Harbor. Perfect for a more refined dining experience, 1637 Restaurant captures the essence of coastal Maine with every dish.
The seafood menu is a masterclass in local cuisine. Highlights include their rich and creamy clam chowder, buttery lobster rolls, and seared scallops, all prepared with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. One of the standout dishes is their lobster risotto, a luxurious blend of creamy Arborio rice and perfectly cooked Maine lobster, finished with a hint of lemon zest. For those seeking variety, the restaurant also features non-seafood options, ensuring there’s something for every palate.
The service at 1637 Restaurant is attentive and professional, enhancing the overall dining experience. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply indulging in a meal after a day of exploring York, 1637 Restaurant provides a perfect blend of coastal charm, elegance, and the finest in Maine’s seafood offerings.
6. Nick’s Beachside Grille: Fresh, Casual Seafood Right by the Beach
For those who prefer a laid-back atmosphere with the taste of fresh seafood, Nick’s Beachside Grille is an ideal destination. Located just steps from the beach, this casual eatery offers a simple yet satisfying seafood menu with an emphasis on local ingredients and bold flavors. Perfect for a post-beach meal, Nick’s specializes in classics like lobster rolls, fried clams, and crispy fish and chips, all served with generous portions and a beachside vibe.
What makes Nick’s unique is its relaxed, family-friendly environment combined with consistently fresh seafood. Their lobster rolls, packed with sweet, tender lobster meat, are a local favorite, and their fish tacos, made with fresh-caught white fish, offer a delightful twist on traditional beach fare. The outdoor seating provides a perfect spot to take in the ocean breeze while enjoying your meal, making it a go-to spot for both locals and visitors.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite between beach outings or settling in for a relaxed dinner, Nick’s Beachside Grille offers an authentic taste of York’s coastal seafood in a casual, welcoming setting.
7. Dockside Restaurant: Hidden Gem with Waterfront Views
Tucked away on Harris Island, Dockside Restaurant is one of York’s best-kept secrets, offering both delicious seafood and stunning waterfront views. Family-owned and operated since 1952, this hidden gem combines rustic charm with a classic Maine seafood menu. Its location provides diners with sweeping views of York Harbor, making every meal a peaceful escape from the crowds.
The menu at Dockside features a range of fresh, local seafood options, from lobster bisque to crispy fried haddock. Their signature lobster bake, served with all the traditional New England fixings, is a standout, offering an authentic taste of Maine’s coastal cuisine. Pair your meal with a glass of wine or one of their craft beers, and enjoy the sunset over the harbor from their outdoor deck.
With its relaxed atmosphere, friendly service, and unmatched waterfront views, Dockside Restaurant is perfect for those looking to savor York’s seafood in a serene, picturesque setting. Whether you’re dining al fresco on a warm summer evening or enjoying the cozy interior during cooler months, Dockside offers a quintessential Maine dining experience that’s both welcoming and unforgettable.
Conclusion
York, Maine’s seafood scene is a treasure trove for food enthusiasts, offering a delightful mix of fresh, locally sourced dishes and stunning coastal views. Whether you’re indulging in lobster rolls with a lighthouse backdrop at Fox’s Lobster House, savoring upscale seafood at Shearwater, or enjoying a casual beachside meal at Nick’s, York’s seafood restaurants capture the essence of Maine’s coastal charm.
For those seeking a relaxing stay while exploring these culinary gems, York Cabin provides the perfect retreat. Combining modern elegance with the natural beauty of Maine, York Cabin offers a serene home base just minutes from the town’s best seafood spots, ensuring your visit is both delicious and memorable.
