York, Maine, may be best known for its picturesque beaches, scenic coastal walks, and historic landmarks, but for food lovers, it’s also home to some incredible pizza spots. Whether you’re looking for a family-friendly atmosphere, a quick bite after a day of exploring, or a gourmet pizza with unique toppings, York has something to satisfy every craving. This guide will take you on a tour of the best places to grab a slice, each offering a distinct flavor of the town’s culinary scene. From artisan creations to classic takeout, we’ve uncovered the top four pizza spots in York that will leave you craving more.
And after a day of exploring York’s hidden gems, York Cabin is the perfect place to retreat and unwind.
Best Pizza in York, Maine
York, Maine might be a small coastal town, but it packs a punch when it comes to its pizza scene. Whether you’re looking for thin, crispy crusts, unique toppings, or a classic slice, the pizza offerings here are as diverse as they are delicious. Many of York’s pizzerias take advantage of local ingredients, infusing their pies with fresh, regional flavors that give each bite a taste of Maine’s charm.
What makes York’s pizza culture stand out is its blend of old and new. You’ll find long-standing institutions that have been serving locals and tourists for decades, side by side with newer, gourmet pizzerias that offer inventive toppings and modern twists on traditional recipes. From casual, family-friendly spots where you can grab a slice after a day at the beach, to more refined restaurants perfect for a night out, York’s pizza scene caters to all types of food lovers.
Let’s dive into the top pizza spots York has to offer, showcasing the best locations for enjoying a slice while taking in the coastal charm. Whether you’re a pizza purist or an adventurous eater, York’s diverse options will leave you satisfied and coming back for more.
1. Village Pizza: A Local Classic with Artisan Options
For anyone seeking a slice of local flavor, Village Pizza in York has long been a community favorite, offering a perfect balance of classic and artisan pizza options. Established as a family-run pizzeria, Village Pizza is known for its friendly atmosphere, welcoming both locals and tourists with equal warmth. Its menu features everything from traditional cheese and pepperoni pies to more creative, artisan-style pizzas topped with ingredients like spinach, feta, and grilled chicken.
What makes Village Pizza stand out is its commitment to quality and consistency. The dough is made fresh daily, creating a perfect base that’s crispy on the outside yet soft on the inside. The pizzas are generously topped with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, ensuring that every bite is flavorful and satisfying. While the classics are always a hit, it’s the artisan pizzas that really steal the show. The combination of gourmet toppings and hand-crafted dough results in a pizza experience that’s both comforting and elevated.
Village Pizza’s convenient location near downtown York makes it a popular stop for families, beachgoers, and anyone looking for a relaxed, delicious meal. Whether you’re dining in or taking a pizza to go, Village Pizza provides a delicious, reliable option that perfectly captures the essence of a local pizzeria with a twist of creativity.
2. Woody’s Brick Oven Pizza: A Rustic Favorite for Pizza Lovers
Woody’s Brick Oven Pizza is a hidden gem in York, perfect for those seeking a rustic pizza experience. Known for its brick oven cooking, Woody’s delivers a perfectly crispy crust that elevates every bite. The menu offers nearly a dozen toppings, including unique options like black forest ham and square pepperoni, catering to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters.
What sets Woody’s apart is not only the quality of the pizza but also the friendly, welcoming staff, who add a personal touch to the dining experience. The atmosphere is cozy, making it an ideal spot for a casual family meal or a quick stop after exploring York’s scenic attractions. Woody’s combines the best of classic pizza with a warm, inviting ambiance, making it a must-visit for any pizza lover visiting York
3. Anthony’s Food Shop: The Best Pizza Takeout in Town
Anthony’s Food Shop is a hidden gem in York, known for serving some of the best pizza takeout in town. While it may look like a simple food shop at first glance, Anthony’s has built a loyal following thanks to its consistently high-quality pizza. Whether you’re looking for a quick slice to go or a full pie to take back to the beach, Anthony’s is the go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.
What sets Anthony’s apart is the attention to detail in their pizza-making process. The dough is freshly made each day, resulting in a perfect balance of chewy and crispy textures. The sauce is tangy and flavorful, while the cheese is generously applied, melting into each bite. Toppings range from classic favorites like pepperoni and sausage to more gourmet options like roasted vegetables and fresh basil. For those who prefer gluten-free options, Anthony’s offers an excellent gluten-free crust that doesn’t compromise on flavor.
Located conveniently near the beach, Anthony’s Food Shop is perfect for grabbing a pizza after a day of sun and surf. With its quick, friendly service and unbeatable flavors, it’s no wonder this spot is considered the best place for takeout pizza in York. Whether you’re feeding a family or craving a slice for yourself, Anthony’s delivers on taste and convenience.
4. York54: Gourmet Pizza and Ocean Views
York54 is more than just a pizza spot—it’s a gourmet dining experience that offers exceptional quality paired with stunning ocean views. Situated close to the coastline, York54 is known for its unique approach to pizza, combining artisanal techniques with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The restaurant has built a reputation for serving some of the best gourmet pizzas in York, with a menu that features creative toppings like roasted garlic, fresh basil, and house-made mozzarella.
The ambiance of York54 elevates the pizza experience to a new level. With seating options that allow you to gaze out over the Atlantic Ocean, it’s the perfect spot for a relaxing meal after a day spent exploring the town. The combination of the fresh sea air, the sound of waves in the background, and a slice of gourmet pizza creates a truly memorable dining experience.
What really sets York54 apart is its attention to detail. The dough is hand-stretched, and the wood-fired oven gives each pizza a perfectly crispy crust with a hint of smokiness. From classics like Margherita to more adventurous options like truffle mushroom, there’s a pizza for every palate. York54 delivers not only on flavor but also on an authentic, elevated pizza experience.
Gluten-Free and Artisan Pizza Options in York
York, Maine, offers a diverse range of pizza options that cater to dietary needs and more sophisticated palates, including gluten-free and artisan pizzas. Whether you’re avoiding gluten or seeking a more refined pizza experience, many of York’s top pizza spots ensure that no one misses out on a delicious slice.
For gluten-free pizza lovers, Anthony’s Food Shop provides one of the best options in town. Their gluten-free crust is a hit with locals, offering a texture that’s crisp yet chewy—something that’s difficult to achieve in gluten-free baking. The pizzas are loaded with the same fresh ingredients and high-quality toppings that make their traditional pies stand out, ensuring a satisfying meal for everyone.
On the artisan side, York54 takes pizza to the next level with their gourmet creations. Their menu features unique combinations like prosciutto and arugula or truffle mushrooms, bringing bold flavors to the table. Each artisan pizza is made with hand-stretched dough and topped with locally sourced ingredients, offering a perfect balance of innovation and tradition.
Whether you’re looking for gluten-free options or want to explore artisan pizza creations, York’s pizza scene ensures that every dietary preference and flavor profile is covered, making it easy to find a delicious and memorable meal.
Conclusion
York, Maine’s pizza scene offers something for every taste, from gourmet pies with ocean views at York54 to family-friendly favorites at Wild Willy’s. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice, a gluten-free option, or a takeout pizza from Anthony’s Food Shop, you’re sure to find delicious options across town. With local gems like Village Pizza offering both traditional and artisan choices, York has become a destination where pizza lovers can truly indulge.
For visitors looking to explore the town’s food scene and enjoy a luxurious stay, York Cabin provides the perfect base. With its blend of coastal charm and modern comfort, York Cabin offers a serene retreat after a day of enjoying the best pizzas in York.
